Menu

This site is maintained by the Waking Down Community Network. It is offered as a support for those involved in the work of Waking Down in Mutuality (WDM), but because the bulk of the material here is not written or reviewed by WDM teachers, the content should not be assumed to represent WDM dharma.

Username:

Password:



Make a New Account

Forget your username or password?

The Prayer Circle

Karen Beratta–employment
Talia Miller–radiant health
Nino–health
Elijah Pearlman–healthy development
(Instructions)

Search





Advanced Search

Empathy, Alienized

by: Michael

Sat Nov 07, 2009 at 16:29 PM PST


"Embracing change is never easy, but the reward for doing so can be greater than anything you could imagine."—Anna, charismatic leader of the murderous space lizards

The remake of the '80s alien invasion TV series V premiered Tuesday, November 3, 2009 on ABC. On the surface, like the original, it set up a conflict between the people of Earth and the Visitors, advanced aliens pretending friendship while planning world domination. But it was difficult to ignore the way in which that conflict was framed: those who value tradition and self-reliance (humanity) versus those who value empathy and holism (murderous space lizards).

The story has already spread widely that the episode was a comment, either on the Obama administration, or on the views of the president's most extreme opponents. The show's creators deny this. Time will tell, I suppose.

But more generally, the show points out a characteristic perspective of our times. As far as many traditionalists are concerned, those of us who advocate for certain kinds of change in the world might as well be murderous space lizards. Even if we say we want co-existence, that we exist at all signifies an end to the world of the past. And besides, that's exactly what murderous space lizards would say…

This tension has existed for a long time, of course. But some people sense (rightly or wrongly) that we've reached a tipping point. So tensions deepen.

It occurs to me that the dichotomy in V so far can be expressed in Spiral Dynamics terms, in that humans are being painted as Orange and Blue, while murderous space lizards are Green and Yellow.*

I'll be watching the show attentively to see whether this framing continues. In the meantime, when I engage with those of a more traditionalist view, I'll try not to come across too space lizard-y.

"The intent goes beyond just healing. We want to provide complete medical services to all."
"You're talking about universal health care."
"I believe that's what you call it, yes."
—Interview with Anna, charismatic leader of the murderous space lizards

* When the subject of Spiral Dynamics comes up, usually I have to log an objection to the characterizations of Green and Yellow in Spiral Dynamics Integral, in favor of the original theory of Clare Graves. In this case, however, I think either interpretation works equally well.

Tags: , (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email
Empathy, Alienized | 4 comments
A few comments (0.00 / 0)
I remember that series from the 80s, but won't be watching any of it this time around since I can no longer receive ABC or CBS since the digital conversion.  Which is fine with me -- the idea that there is nothing better to fill up the air waves than a remake of "V" is rather disheartening to me!

On the other hand, your post raises some interesting philosophical ideas.  I don't profess to really understand the whole Spiral Dynamics thing, but your comments make me wonder if the Borg would also be considered as more "evolved" and more open to change than humans.

I also find it interesting that we would consider those space lizards as "murderous" when, as I recall from the earlier series, they came here mainly in search of food.  Yet human culture generally doesn't consider our behavior towards others animals "murderous" when we hunt them as food, or confine them for the purpose of raising them solely to be eaten.

And their "enslavement" of humans for forced labor isn't really that different from our enslavement of fellow human beings or even our domestication of other animals to labor for us.

To me, it's an intriguing reminder of how much we consider humans to be the top of the pecking order and to have the right to "use" any other life form.  When another species shows up, even in a fictional context, and we are no longer on top, then we label them as murderous because of how they treat us.  How dare they!?!  Don't they know how important humans are?  They can't treat us like that!

OK, so maybe it's not quite where the producers are trying to lead their audience to, but I find it though-provoking.

Joy


Meat and obscure irony (0.00 / 0)

While I'm not a vegetarian, I do agree that we should keep in mind that animals are killed to provide us meat. I'm puzzled by those who readily eat meat when purchased from a restaurant or a store but regard hunting for food as cruel.

I think where the "ick" factor comes into play regarding intelligent alients who would eat us is that we supposedly could communicate with language. I expect that there'd be a taboo in our culture against eating anything that we can talk to, but since we mostly can only talk amongst ourselves, it's not readily apparent. We don't eat monkeys in the West, but if we did, we might draw the line at monkeys who learned sign language.

That said, it became clear to me from your response that my review wasn't fair to those who hadn't already seen the show. I was having fun, but gave a misleading impression. The aliens aren't really empathic and holistic. Rather, that's the nature of the disguise they're attempting to weave. The impression is given, therefore, that those who express empathy and holism are not to be trusted. This, then, ties into the recent trends of 'tea parties,' fears of socialist conspiracies, and the association of government social programs with fascism. Hence, my sarcasm: of course, advocates of sharing, nurture, and healing are murderous! We've seen through their facade, and they'll never lure us with pipe dreams of universal healthcare!

As far as a remake of V being disheartening, I think they're trying to follow the example of Battlestar Galactica: a painfully bad show from decades ago that was recently remade into one of the finest things on television. Based on the premiere alone, they might have a shot at it. Peculiar cultural messages aside, it's tightly written, well performed, and has excellent production values. Oh, and since you don't have access to ABC, you can see the episodes after they air at hulu.com, if you're so inclined.



[ Parent ]
Ulterior meanings (0.00 / 0)
Michael, I knew you were not seriously calling the aliens humane and nurturing!  But to your point about the political allegory, I wonder if the ulterior message (if there is one at all) could be as simple as "universal health care has about as much chance of becoming reality as a sci-fi TV mini-series".

As far as watching the new and improved V, I have no interest.  Now if someone would do a remake of Babylon 5, that would be a whole different matter!  


Okay, then (0.00 / 0)

Well, having thought I didn't explain enough, I'll settle for having over-explained. Anyway, last night's episode 2 had little or none of the implied liberal bashing of the premiere, which speaks well for the health of the series. Battlestar Galactica sometimes did similar things, having one episode apparently veering to one end of the political spectrum, only to reverse itself the following week.

I wouldn't want another Babylon 5 unless it were still under the aegis of Michael Straczynski. But if it were, wouldn't that be a fine thing?



[ Parent ]
Empathy, Alienized | 4 comments

Speak it!

Mutuality.net relies on community participation. It is an online venue for users to post their thoughts, feelings, questions, observations, and dreams; a virtual space for discussion and inquiry. Add your voice to the conversation today!

Mutuality Matters

Eduardo's colorful and informative magazine Mutuality Matters can be downloaded below. These are print-ready PDF's—enjoy.

New!

  • Issue 9. August/September '08 (1.4 MB)

Past issues:

Every Human Has Rights

Mutuality.net is an online community for students and friends of Waking Down in Mutuality (WDM).

Questions or problems with the site? Contact the Web Admin. Powered by: SoapBlox